Think On Your Feet: Altra vs. Keen Product Review

I have a pair of Men’s Voyageur that scaled an active volcano and traversed 4 continents. After meeting an expert hiker about his annual traversal of the Appalachian Trail, he recommended researching Altra hiking shoes. I was intrigued. My main problem with Keens is the weight. The toe protection is fantastic but the added weight strains me over long periods of time and makes it difficult to climb. This culminated with me falling down temple stairs in Cambodia and bruising my knee cap – making it even harder to trek.

After research, below are data points comparing Altra and Keen shoes.

For me, main factors are Weight, Toe Protection, and desired terrain. I chose the lighter option, Altra, which allows me to go farther and feel more secure during a trek. However, it has less protection and terrain versatility. Both have similar water resistance but Keens are overall better in this category.

I prefer to spend more time choosing where and when to explore rather than wearing a heavier boot, draining my stamina, and causing an unsafe situation during the adventure.

Altra Lone Peak ALL-WTHR Mid 2 Review Highlights:

Comfort & Support:

Accommodating toe splay and foot swelling during long hikes or warm weather.
Soft, easy-to-break-in textile fabric upper and a 25mm stack height providing adequate trail impact protection.
Altra Ego midsole ensuring better cushioning than previous Altra models, offers bouncy cushioning and protects against rough terrain.
Soft, making them feel more like a shoe than a traditional boot.
Adjustable lacing system for personalized support and ankle support

Traction:

Solid traction on various terrains with a Duratread sole and forefoot traction lugs improving climbing ability.
Shallow yet sharp lugs for better grip on softer materials (i.e. mud)
Not ideal for tasks like edging or kicking steps due to sole flexibility.

Water Resistance:

eVent fabric provides waterproofing, withstands brief submersion.
Not suitable for extended exposure to wet weather but dries quickly.

Weight & Durability:

Remarkably lightweight (1.83lbs), ideal for fastpackers and thru-hikers.
Sacrifices durability for weight; expected lifespan around 200-300 miles.

Ideal Consumer:

This lightweight hiking boot resembles more of a comfortable shoe than a traditional boot.

Those Seeking Comfortable Hiking Experience: Wider feet or those who appreciate toe splay during hikes.Hikers prioritizing comfort and a soft, easy-going stride over multi-day durability.

Fastpackers & Thru-Hikers: Individuals desiring the agility and comfort of a trail runner. Prefer the added ankle support and water resistance of a mid-cut boot. Best suited for trail use or off-trail by experienced and agile users. Not recommended for heavy-duty tasks requiring rigidity or prolonged wear.

KEEN Voyageur Hiking Boots Review Highlights:

Comfort & Support:

Contoured heel lock with S3 heel support (Shock, Stability, Suspension).
Shock-absorbent heel for enhanced comfort with each step
Offers stability and support reducing the risk of ankle sprains

Traction:

Rubber outsole with 4mm multi-directional lugs for exceptional traction
Provides excellent grip on various terrains
Non-marking outsoles prevent marks on indoor surfaces

Water Resistance:

Made from water-resistant leather and mesh with moisture-wicking textiles
Among the most breathable KEEN boots
Excellent ventilation for superior breathability and reduces foot sweat, ideal for hot conditions

Weight & Durability:

Weight: 16.54oz / 469g.
Equipped with ESS torsion stability shank for shock absorption and puncture prevention
Limited additional durability features compared to other KEEN models

Ideal Consumer:

Warm Weather Hikers: Perfect for upcoming warmer months due to breathability. Offers excellent stability and support for various terrains

Comfort-Seeking Hikers: Those prioritizing comfort and reduced foot sweat in hot conditions. Provides shock-absorbent heel and stability to prevent ankle sprains.

Versatile Terrain Explorers: Hikers looking for reliable traction on diverse landscapes. Non-marking outsoles suitable for both outdoor and indoor use.

Both are great shoes but it depends on your preferences and desired terrain.

Safe Travels!